Home » Opinion » Pilgrims, Thanksgiving, and Socialism

Pilgrims, Thanksgiving, and Socialism

By Frank McDonough

In September 1620 the Mayflower finally sailed from Plymouth, England, carrying about 102 passengers, roughly a third of them Separatists seeking to practice their faith free of the Church of England, the rest “Strangers” recruited by London merchant investors. After a hard 66-day crossing they reached Cape Cod in November, far north of their intended Virginia destination.

There, 41 adult men signed the Mayflower Compact, binding themselves into a “civil body politic” to enact “just and equal laws… for the general good of the colony,” invoking the glory of God and the advancement of the Christian faith.

They faced a “hideous and desolate wilderness.” The first winter killed nearly half the company, including Governor Bradford’s wife. Survivors lived for months aboard the ship. In the spring of 1621, Wampanoag Indians, especially the English-speaking Squanto, showed them how to plant corn, fish, and survive.

That autumn the settlers held a harvest celebration. Edward Winslow recorded that they feasted for three days with Massasoit and some ninety of his men, who contributed five deer. The English had fowl in abundance. It was a diplomatic and practical gathering, thanks to God, but not yet the formal national holiday later invented around it.

What is less often emphasized is the economic arrangement the settlers had accepted. Their contract with the Merchant Adventurers required that, for seven years, land and produce be held in common, with equal shares distributed from a common store.

Bradford later described the results with unusual candor. The system, he wrote, “was found to breed much confusion and discontent and retard much employment that would have been to their benefit and comfort.” Young men fit for labor “did repine that they should spend their time and strength to work for other men’s wives and children without any recompense.”

The strong received no more than the weak. Even among “godly and sober men,” taking away private property and imposing community of goods produced injustice and slack effort—as if, Bradford noted, the planners were “wiser than God.”

In the spring of 1623, facing continued scarcity, Bradford and the colony’s leaders assigned each family a private parcel of land “for present use.” They could plant corn “every man for his own particular.”

The change, Bradford recorded, “had very good success, for it made all hands very industrious, so as much more corn was planted than otherwise would have been.” Women who had previously pleaded weakness now entered the fields with their children. From that point the chronic hunger of the early years largely ended.

The lesson Bradford drew was practical, not just ideological. Incentives matter. People work harder when they keep the fruits of their own labor for their own families. The Pilgrims did not set out to test socialism; they accepted a temporary common-stock contract demanded by their investors and abandoned it when it demonstrably failed.

What remains useful is Bradford’s own observation: even among the devout, a system that severs effort from reward produces confusion, resentment, and less output. Private plots produced the opposite.

The harvest celebration of 1621 was real, and gratitude to the Wampanoag Indians was warranted. But the deeper American Thanksgiving tradition is older and clearer. One hundred sixty-eight years later, President George Washington issued the first national Thanksgiving proclamation:

“Whereas it is the duty of all Nations to acknowledge the providence of Almighty God, to obey his will, to be grateful for his benefits, and humbly to implore his protection and favor… a day of public thanksgiving and prayer to be observed by acknowledging with grateful hearts the many signal favors of Almighty God especially by affording them an opportunity peaceably to establish a form of government for their safety and happiness… To promote the knowledge and practice of true religion and virtue, and the increase of science among them and us—and generally to grant unto all Mankind such a degree of temporal prosperity as He alone knows to be best.”

Washington was not just inventing a new holiday. He was recognizing what the Pilgrims had already lived: that survival, liberty, and prosperity are not automatic. They depend on institutions that align God and human nature with results.

Bradford’s experiment proved the point in the hardest possible laboratory. A system that treats the productive and the idle as identical fails—even among the godly. Private property and the right to keep what you grow succeeded where the common store failed.

That lesson has not aged. Every modern attempt to replace individual incentive with collective equality—whether labeled socialism, democratic socialism, communism or simply “fairness”—reproduces the same pattern Bradford recorded: less effort, more resentment, and thinner harvests.

The Pilgrims learned it the hard way and changed course. The question is whether we will do the same, or whether we will keep insisting we are wiser than both God and the evidence of history.


Frank McDonough is a retired technology executive, former chairman of the Lovettsville Planning Commission, and an active civic voice in the small-town life of Lovettsville.

Comments

Any name-calling and profanity will be taken off. The webmaster reserves the right to remove any offensive posts.

Leave a Comment





Subscribe. Get the news you care about in your inbox.

We don’t spam! See privacy policy.

Continue reading in this news section

More  news